Executive Fraud Blog

A longtime Alfa Corp. insurance agent from northeast Alabama agreed to plead guilty in a fraud scheme involving loans with nearly $5.5 million in outstanding balances.

Prosecutors said James A. Maddox, 60, of Fyffe could receive 20 years imprisonment and a fine of $250,000 for the crime, which began in 1991 and continued until it was uncovered last year.

Maddox is due in court on Thursday for a hearing, but no sentencing date has been set. Prosecutors filed papers outlining the plea agreement on Friday.

Maddox had worked as an agent for the company since 1973.

Alfa filed suit against Maddox last year alleging he used fictitious collateral to obtain loans for himself and loans for customers and then pocketed the money.

Documents in the criminal case show the scheme involved a series of loans that had balances of $5.49 million when it was uncovered last year.

Ronald J. Tenpas, associate deputy attorney general, said his department has recovered $5.3 billion since 1999 from major drug manufacturers in a variety of kickback schemes and overcharges that defrauded Medicaid and Medicare.

Company to Pay $15 Million Penalty and Retain Independent Consultant

2007-14
Washington, D.C., Feb. 6, 2007 - The Securities and Exchange Commission filed settled securities fraud charges against RenaissanceRe Holdings Ltd. (RenRe), a property catastrophe reinsurance company, for creating a sham reinsurance transaction that had no economic substance and no purpose other than to smooth and defer over $26 million of earnings from 2001 to 2002 and 2003. In effect, the transaction enabled RenRe to create a "cookie jar" into which it put excess revenue in one good year, to be pulled out in a future year to increase income.

In settling the Commission's charges, RenRe agreed to an injunction, to retain an independent consultant, and to pay a $15 million civil penalty, among other things.

In September 2006, the Commission charged RenRe's former chairman and chief executive officer, James N. Stanard, RenRe's former controller, Martin J. Merritt, and a former senior vice president of RenRe's principal reinsurance subsidiary, Michael W. Cash. Those charges remain pending in federal court in Manhattan.

Mark K. Schonfeld, Director of the Commission's Northeast Regional Office, said, "This is yet another action arising from our ongoing investigation of the misuse of finite reinsurance products to commit securities fraud. In this case, RenRe essentially played a shell game with its revenue — hiding it in one year when it was not needed, only to reveal it in a later year when it would improve the bottom line."

According to the Commission's complaint, RenRe concocted a sham transaction to smooth its earnings. RenRe used two seemingly unrelated contracts that were, in fact, intertwined to conceal what was in reality simply a round trip of cash. In the first contract, RenRe purported to assign $50 million of receivables at a discount to Inter-Ocean Reinsurance Company, Ltd. in exchange for $30 million in cash, for a net transfer to Inter-Ocean of $20 million. RenRe recorded income of $30 million upon executing the assignment agreement. The remaining $20 million of its $50 million assignment became part of a "bank" or "cookie jar" that RenRe used in later periods to bolster income.

The second contract was a purported reinsurance agreement with Inter-Ocean that was, in fact, a vehicle to refund to RenRe the $20 million transferred under the assignment agreement plus the purported insurance premium paid under the reinsurance agreement. This reinsurance agreement was also a sham. Not only was RenRe certain to meet the conditions for coverage; it also would receive back all of the money paid to Inter-Ocean under the agreements plus investment income earned on the money in the interim, less transactional fees and costs.

RenRe accounted for the sham transaction as if it involved a real reinsurance contract that transferred risk from RenRe to Inter-Ocean when in fact, the complaint alleges, certain of RenRe's senior officers knew that this was not true. RenRe's former controller and former chief executive officer also misrepresented or omitted certain key facts about the transaction to RenRe's auditors. As a result of RenRe's accounting treatment for this transaction, RenRe materially understated income in 2001 and materially overstated income in 2002, at which time it made a "claim" under the "reinsurance" agreement. It then received as apparent reinsurance proceeds the funds it had paid to Inter-Ocean and that Inter-Ocean had held in a trust for RenRe's benefit.

In a Feb. 22, 2005, press release, RenRe announced that it would restate its financial statements for the years ended Dec. 31, 2001, 2002 and 2003. On March 31, 2005, RenRe filed its Form 10-K for the year ended Dec. 31, 2004, which contained restated financial statements for those years. RenRe's former chief executive officer signed and certified the 2004 Form 10-K. However, both the press release and the Form 10-K attributed the restatement of the Inter-Ocean transaction to accounting "errors" due to "the timing of the recognition of Inter-Ocean reinsurance recoverables." These statements were misleading. In fact, the transaction contained no real reinsurance and the company's restated financial statements accounted for the transaction as if it had never occurred. In short, the entire transaction was a sham, and the company both failed to disclose that fact and misrepresented the reasons for the restatement.

The Commission's Charges
The Commission's complaint charges RenRe with securities fraud in violation of Section 17(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5(a), (b), and (c) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and with violating the reporting, books-and-records, and internal controls provisions of Exchange Act Sections 13(a) and 13(b)(2) and Rules 12b-20, 13a-1, 13a-13, and 13b2-1. Without admitting or denying the allegations in the Commission's complaint, RenRe has agreed to settle the Commission's charges. In connection with the settlement, RenRe has agreed to pay a civil penalty of $15 million and nominal disgorgement of $1 and has consented to the entry of a final judgment that permanently enjoins it from future violations of the federal securities laws. RenRe has also consented to undertakings that, among other things, require it to retain an independent consultant to review the design and implementation of the prior review conducted by independent counsel and the additional procedures performed by the company's auditors and make recommendations concerning the adequacy of RenRe's internal controls, audit department, and compliance function. The Commission acknowledges RenRe's cooperation in the investigation.

Fraud in Scotland has rocketed to its highest level in 20 years of official research, say finance experts.
Figures from accountancy firm KPMG reveal about £50m worth of fraud was committed last year - almost three times the 2005 total.

The level has been boosted by major cases, such as that of the Edinburgh banker convicted of a £21m loans scam in June, researchers have reported.

They claim the number of frauds carried out by criminal gangs is also worrying.

Ken Milliken, head of KPMG Scotland's forensic team, said: "They have clearly been stepping up their efforts in the last year, with ID theft, card scams, bank insider frauds, money laundering and cigarette and VAT frauds represented within our figures.

"Despite considerable government efforts to make it harder for such gangs to operate, there is still a long way to go.

"Added to that, with company managers committing nearly £350m of fraud last year, the figures produce a picture of a country where fraud is becoming worryingly deep-rooted."

Scottish courts dealt with 22 fraud cases worth £50.1m in 2006, compared with 15 worth £18m the previous year.

A total of £837m of fraud was committed across the UK last year, with a third of Britain's 277 cases carried out by professional criminals.

Company managers were responsible for 40% of fraud in terms of value.

Last year, Edinburgh bank manager Donald Mackenzie was jailed for embezzling £21m from the Royal Bank of Scotland.

Insurance broker, John Walker, admitted to selling customers of his Midlothian-based business £10m in bogus policies.

In Ayr, the boss of a knitwear company stole more than £250,000 from the firm over a four-year period to fund his gambling habit.

Mr Milliken claimed measures should be put in place to make operating fraud more difficult, as well as creating systems to make it easier to detect.

He added: "The government's recent fraud review, as well as the creation of the new Scottish Crime Campus, are important measures which will help in the fight against fraud.

"But you can't legislate against human nature, which is why fraud will always be around."